Skip to Main Content
Petoskey's logo topPetoskey's logo scroll
  • Twitter pageFacebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
  • MENU
  • ORDER
  • GIFT CARDS
  • DRINKS
  • SPECIALS
  • EVENTS
  • JOBS

Our Menu

Download Menu
MenuHog Island Hoagie MenuFootball Breakfast

Appetizers

Fries or Tater Tots

$7.00
Add Cheese Sauce +$3.00 | Add Skyline Chili +$7.50 | Gravy +$2.00

Onion Rings

$10.00
Imo's Toasted Beef Ravioli photo

Imo's Toasted Beef Ravioli

$18.00

Chicken Tenders & Fries

$17.00
Dips: Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Buffalo, or Honey Mustard | Add Gravy +$2.00

Deep - Fried Pickle Chips

$13.00
Hand-cut, breaded, deep-fried - Chicago Pickle Company

Bavarian Pretzel & Cheese Sauce

$13.00
Basket of 3
Wings photo

Wings

$18.00/8 wings
Buffalo, BBQ, Thai, Lemon Pepper, Old Bay, Sriracha Garlic Parmesan
Wisconsin Cheese Curds photo

Wisconsin Cheese Curds

$17.00
1/2 pound beer-battered & deep-fried curds, served with ranch or marinara.
Poutine photo

Poutine

$14.00
Authentic poutine with fries and Wisconsin cheese curds, covered in a rich gravy | Add Ground Beef or Chicken +$3.00 | Philly Beef +$4.00

Soup & Chili

Smita’s Lentil

Cup $6.00 | Bowl $11.00 • Gluten-free lentil soup with all the right Indian spices.

Minnesota Wild Rice

Cup $7.00 | Bowl $13.00 • Hearty comforting MN favorite, choice of black forest ham or gourmet chicken breast.

Skyline Chili

$8.00/Cup
With shredded cheddar, and diced white onions.

Salads

Chopped

$17.00
Grilled chicken breast, romaine, tomatoes, onions, black olives, cucumber, artichoke hearts, pepperoncini, oregano flake, choice of dressing.

Caesar

$13.00
Romaine, house Caesar dressing, parmesan, croutons, served with lemon wedge • Add Anchovies, Bacon +$3.00 each | Chicken Breast (Fried or Grilled) +$6.50

Flour Tortilla Wraps

Chicken Bacon Ranch

$18.00
Fried or grilled chicken, bacon, iceberg lettuce, tomato, ranch, cheddar.

Buffalo Chicken

$18.00
Fried or grilled Buffalo chicken, mozzarella, tomato, celery, iceberg lettuce, bleu cheese or ranch.

Hoagies

With fries, tots, or coleslaw | On a soft French roll or tortilla wrap | Panini pressed hot if you want • Add Marconi Giardiniera $0.75 | Mama Lil’s Peppers $0.75 | Hot Cherry Peppers $0.75 | Sport peppers $0.75 | Cucumbers $0.50

The Hog Islander (Italian Hoagie) photo

The Hog Islander (Italian Hoagie)

$18.00
Black Forest ham, Genoa salami, ham capocollo, provolone, mortadella, mayo, tomatoes, salt/pepper, pickles, onions, Mama Lil’s peppers, hot cherry peppers, lettuce, oil/vinegar, oregano.

American Hero

$17.50
Black forest ham, Genoa salami, mortadella, white American, mayo, deli mustard, tomatoes, salt/pepper, pickles, onion, pepperoncini, lettuce, oil/vinegar.

Caesar’s Navy

$17.50
Gourmet chicken breast, provolone, Caesar dressing, tomato, salt-pepper, onion, Mama Lil's peppers, feta, chopped romaine, oil/vinegar.

British Armada

$18.00
Black forest ham, chicken breast, seasoned roast beef, white cheddar, mayo, deli mustard, tomato, salt/pepper, onion, pickle, pepperoncini, lettuce, oil/vinegar.

Vashon Veggie

$15.00
Choice of cheese: Provolone, White American, Pepper Jack, or White Cheddar, tomato, onion, bell pepper, cucumber, pepperoncini, spicy giardiniera, lettuce, oil/vinegar, oregano.
Ship Builder photo

Ship Builder

Chicken $17.50 | Roast Beef $18.00 • Choose one meat or half and half of: Gourmet Chicken Breast, Seasoned Roast Beef, or Black Forest Ham | Cheese: Provolone, White American, Pepper Jack, or White Cheddar with mayo, deli mustard, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, pepperoncini, salt/pepper, oil/vinegar | Add Creamy Horseradish $0.50 | Add extra meats: (+$3.00 each) Black Forest Ham, Gourmet Chicken Breast, Seasoned Roast Beef | (+$1.50 each) Genoa Salami, Mortadella, Hot Ham Capocollo

Vienna Dogs

With fries, tots, or coleslaw | All Beef Natural Casing | Vienna Poppyseed Buns

Ballpark Dog

$12.00
Chicago style relish, ketchup, yellow mustard, diced onions.

Chicago Dog

$14.00
Sports peppers, tomato, celery salt, Chicago relish, yellow mustard, pickle spear.

Iceland Dog

$15.00
Fried onions, diced white onions, imported Icelandic condiments (remoulade, mustard, tomato/apple ketchup).

Seattle Dog

$14.00
Cream cheese, grilled onions, Mama Lil’s & hot cherry peppers.

Cincinnati Dog

$15.00
Skyline Chili, shredded cheddar, white onions, yellow mustard.

Burgers

1/4 lb. patties | Sub Black Bean Patty on any Burger +$3.00

The 888 Burger

$8.88
American cheese, onion, lettuce, tomato, pickles, burger sauce • Sides: Fries, Tots +$3.00 | Herr’s Chips +$2.50 | Onion Rings +$4.00 • Add: Bacon +$2.00 | Xtra Patty +$4.00 | Fried Egg +$2.00 | Xtra Cheese +$1.50 | Grilled Mushrooms +$1.25 | Grilled Onions +$0.50 | Fried Onions +$0.75 | Jalapeños +$0.75
Green Olive Burger photo

Green Olive Burger

$15.00
Green olives, crispy fried onions, cream cheese, grilled onions, mayo | Served with Fries, Tots, or Coleslaw.

The Brick Burger

$17.00
Wisconsin brick cheese, grilled mushrooms, onions, fried onions, Marconi spicy giardiniera, garlic Worcestershire mayo | With fries, tots, or coleslaw.

Hot Sandwiches

Served with Fries, Tots, or Coleslaw.

The Brick Club

$18.00
Triple decker sandwich with gourmet chicken breast, Black Forest ham, crispy bacon, white American cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo on Texas toast.

The Wilensky

$16.00
A Montreal favorite since 1932 | Mortadella, Genoa salami, smash-fried on a bun, provolone, yellow mustard.

Chicken Deluxe

$18.00
Crispy fried or grilled chicken breast, white American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, grilled onions, mayo, on brioche bun | Add Hot Cherry Peppers for an extra punch +$0.75

Chipotle / Ranch Chicken

$18.00
Panini pressed | Thin sliced gourmet chicken breast, pepper jack cheese, tomato, Mama Lil’s peppers, hot cherry peppers, grilled onion, slathered in spicy chipotle ranch sauce on soft French roll.

Chicken Parm

$18.00
Crispy chicken breast, parmesan, marinara, mozzarella on soft French roll.

Cheesesteak

$18.00
Philly Beef or Gourmet Chicken Breast | Grilled onions, bell peppers, mushrooms | Cheese: White American, Provolone, White Cheddar, Pepper Jack, WI Brick cheese (+$1.00), or House Cheese Sauce, on soft French roll | Add Mama Lil's or Hot Cherry Peppers +$0.75

French Dip

$18.00
Seasoned roast beef blanched in savory jus, grilled onions, provolone, on soft French roll, au jus.

Italian Beef

$18.00
Seasoned roast beef blanched in savory jus, provolone, grilled onions, Marconi hot giardiniera, and pepperoncini, on a soft French roll, au jus.

Midwest Walleye

Wild Caught from Minnesota | Beer-Battered

Fish and Chips

$19.75
With coleslaw, tartar.

Petoskey's Pizzas

14" square cut pies cooked in our wood-fired oven | Red Sauce Base or White Sauce Base +$2.00 | Topped With 100% Wisconsin Mozzarella | Gluten-Free crust on any pizza +$6.00

The Great Mike Petoskey photo

The Great Mike Petoskey

$35.00
Pepperoni, Canadian bacon, Italian sausage, black olive, bell pepper, mushroom, onion.

Detroiter

$35.00
Bacon, pepperoni, Italian sausage, tomato, jalapeño, onion.

Mackinac Island

$28.00
Canadian bacon, pineapple, jalapeño.

On Wisconsin!

$33.00
Wisconsin brick cheese, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, mushrooms, and green olives.

Blue Earth Minnesota

$26.00
Bell pepper, black olive, mushroom, onion.
Relaxed Viking photo

Relaxed Viking

$31.00
White garlic sauce, artichoke hearts, roasted garlic, Mama Lil’s peppers, feta.
Kraken Bait photo

Kraken Bait

$28.00
Pepperoni, bacon, tomato, hot honey drizzle.

Meat Me in St. Louis

$35.00
Italian sausage, Canadian bacon, pepperoni, Provel cheese.

Chicken Bacon Ranch

$35.00
White garlic sauce, chicken breast, bacon, tomato, ranch drizzle - try with a drizzle of Buffalo sauce.

Build Your Own Pizza

$22.00
Cheese Pizza • Add (+$1.50 ea): Green Olives, Sauerkraut, Mushroom, Onion, Pineapple, Jalapeño, Tomato, Black Olives, Bell Pepper, Roasted Garlic, Hot Cherry Peppers, Mike’s Hot Honey | (+$2.50 ea): Artichoke, Mama Lil’s Peppers, Marconi Hot Giardiniera, feta | (+$3.00 ea): Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Bacon, Canadian Bacon, Ground Beef | (+$6.50): Deep-Fried or Grilled Chicken Breast

Specialty Cheeses

Sub Wisconsin Brick Cheese

$2.00

Sub Provel Cheese

$6.50
From St Louis

Hot Cherry Peppers – hot; Mama Lil’s - sweet, bright; Pepperoncini - mild, tangy; Giardiniera - mild, salty, crunchy (medly of pickled veggies) | Cheeses: White American, White Cheddar, Provolone, Pepperjack, Gouda

Hoagies

Cold

The Hog Islander (Italian Hoagie) photo

The Hog Islander (Italian Hoagie)

$17.00
Black Forest ham, Genoa salami, hot ham coppacolla, provolone, mortadella, mayo, tomatoes, salt/pepper, pickles, onions, Mama Lil’s peppers, hot cherry peppers, lettuce, oil/vinegar, oregano

American Hero

$16.00
Black Forest ham, Genoa salami, mortadella, white American, mayo, deli mustard, tomatoes, salt/pepper, pickles, onion, pepperoncini, lettuce, oil/vinegar

Caesar’s Navy

$16.00
Gourmet chicken breast, provolone, Caesar dressing, tomato, salt/pepper, onion, Mama Lil's peppers, feta, chopped romaine, oil/vinegar.

50,000 Horsepower

$16.00/+
Chicken - $16.00 | Roast Beef - $17.00 • Gourmet chicken breast or seasoned roast beef, provolone, horseradish, deli mustard, tomato, salt/pepper, pickles, onion, pepperoncini, lettuce, oil/vinegar.

Ship Builder

$16.00
Choose Meat: Gourmet Chicken Breast, Seasoned Roast Beef (+$1.00), or Black Forest Ham | Choose Cheese: Provolone, White American, Pepper Jack, or White Cheddar with mayo, deli mustard, tomato, salt/pepper, pickles, onion, pepperoncini, lettuce, oil/vinegar | Xtra Meat +$4.00 | Xtra Cheese +$2.00

Vashon Veggie

$14.00
Choice of cheese, tomato, onion, green peppers, pepperoncini, giardiniera, lettuce, oil/vinegar, oregano.

Saturday and Sunday mornings. Opens at 9am for all the early games

Menu

Breakfast Hoagie

$15.00
2 scrambled eggs, bacon, Black Forest ham, choice of cheese: provolone, Swiss, white American, pepper jack, white cheddar - wrapped in a flour tortilla or soft French roll | Get a kickstart with a Petoskey's Bloody Mary and a Heidelberg back, or Xavie's Masterful Michelada
  • Order
  • Jobs